Use the following items to solve this puzzle:

For v.1 of the game: pizza (Toolbox envelope); for v.2 of the game pizza in the pizza box (Loose in game box)
Cheese (Victim 4 Evidence envelope)
Circle degrees sheet (Victim 4 Evidence envelope)
Grinding Your Gears sheet (Victim 4 Evidence envelope)
Map of USA (Victim 4 Evidence envelope)
Large Gears (3, in Toolbox envelope)
Map of Oaks Hollow (Toolbox envelope)
Optional: an analog watch or clock for reference

Note: the small gears in the Victim 4 Evidence envelope (v.2 only) are decorative

Gather the values from the following actions on the Grinding Your Gears sheet to decode the message:

Step 1: Pizza toppings

Use the Cheese to help you orient the Pizza with the correct topping on top.
Then use the Circle degrees to determine which angle each topping on the Grinding Your Gears is located at.
Finally use the Circle degrees with the Red gear to find which letters match the degrees of each topping.

Onion 0/360 C

Mushroom 130 H

Pineapple 315 E

Pepperoni 180 C

Cheese 90 K

Anchovies 45 N

Pepper 270 E

Step 2: Time

Use the Circle degrees to determine which angle the big hand (minute hand) is at for each time on the Grinding Your Gears sheet
Then use the Circle degrees with the Blue gear to find which letters match the degrees of each time.

12:35 7 (240) O

3:15 3 (0/360) F

7:50 10 (150) F

5:05 5 (60) O

8:45 9 (180) R

Step 3: States Longitude/Latitude

Find each state listed on the Grinding Your Gears sheet on the US map.
If the state is listed horizontally, find the latitude (or parallel) line that runs through the state; if it is vertical, find the longitude (or meridian) line.
Finally, use the Circle degrees with the Green gear to find which letter matches each longitude or latitude value.

Oregon 45 R

Illinois 90 E

Washington 120 S

Alaska 150 T

Louisiana 30 E

Maine 45 R

The complete message is “Check NE of Forrester." On the map, just northeast of the statue of Forrester is Peripheral Park.

Toolbox Puzzle

Hints